Epistemic state

How sure the system is

Every fact is KNOWN, CONFLICTED or UNKNOWN, and anything a machine proposes is PROPOSED until a person or a policy promotes it. Ontonio says which, out loud.

STATE · TWO DIRECTIONS, THREE OUTCOMES Declared from the top, proposed from the wire. Where they meet is the state. TOP DOWN · the ontology is declaredObjects, links and constraints, from an industry pack. Ids are fixed; labels are the vertical’s vocabulary.BOTTOM UP · the wire proposesConnectors, sensors and models emit PROPOSED facts with provenance. Nothing arrives already true.WHERE THEY MEET · DERIVED AT THE DATABASECustomerdeclared + one source agreesKNOWNInvoicedeclared + two sources disagreeCONFLICTEDIncidentproposed, not yet promotedUNKNOWNREUSE · GENERALSchema.orgFOAFDublin CoreSKOSoptionalREUSE · DOMAINIndustry packsFIBOGoodRelationsyour ownoptionalKNOWN · promoted, provenance on fileCONFLICTED · two sources disagree, surfaced not hiddenUNKNOWN · proposed, awaiting policy and a person

Most systems store a value and imply certainty. Discern stores the value and its state. KNOWN means a promoted fact with provenance. CONFLICTED means two sources disagree and neither has been chosen. UNKNOWN means nobody has said, and the honest answer is "I don't know".

A model proposes, never promotes. Whatever a model, a connector or a sensor writes enters as PROPOSED. Promotion is a policy decision or a human one. That single rule is why a wrong guess cannot quietly become the truth.

The state travels with the answer. A customer who asks about opening hours during a conflict hears both times and that a person is checking. Nobody is told a confident wrong number.

Worked example · Opening hours on a Sunday

The seed says the front desk opens at eight. A staff message says nine on Sundays. The fact is now CONFLICTED. Ontonio answers with both and flags it. Staff confirm nine. The fact is KNOWN again, with the confirmation as its source.

a worked example in generic terms; every operation renames the labels, the shapes do not change